Late 18th Century French Binding Structures: Tools, Techniques and Materials. A Presentation For The Guild of Book Workers Standards of Excellence Seminar

Last weekend  I gave a 2.5 hour presentation of my 18th century French binding workshop for the Guild of Book Workers (GBW) Standards of Excellence conference in Tucson, Arizona.   And I agreed to do it four times, over a two day period. It was quite difficult to condense essentially a week long class into a 2.5 hour presentation, and tiring to repeat it four times. Fortunately, a number of  guild members offered provocative and challenging questions/ opinions which helped me to stay engaged.

The GBW Standards, which started in 1982, have had this format in an attempt to keep the presentations intimate.  However,  according to Don Etherington, in his autobiography, Bookbinding and Conservation: A Sixty-Year Odyssey of Art and Craftwhich is an important history not only of Etherington, but of book conservation generally  in America–originally the attendance was capped at 100 attendees and presenters repeated presentations only three times. It is perhaps the single instance in which the old timers had it a bit easier than we do.  Hopefully, due to cost effective video, future seminars might be able to reduce the strain and repetition for the presenters, while maintaining the essential nature of the Standards experience, and perhaps even improving the transmission of information?  The GBW seems to be moving forward with new technologies- they have even started a blog, currently with an overview of Martha Little’s presentation. At some point in the future, an edited  video will be available for purchase from the GBW of all four presentations.

LATE 18TH CENTURY FRENCH BINDING STRUCTURES:

TOOLS, TECHNIQUES AND MATERIALS

PRESENTED BY JEFFREY S. PEACHEY

THE 2010 GUILD OF BOOK WORKERS STANDARDS OF EXCELLENCE SEMINAR TUCSON, ARIZONA

In this presentation, I will discuss and demonstrate a number of aspects of late 18th century French bookbinding structures, mainly focusing on the ubiquitous stained, full calf binding style. This time period is important because it represents the end of in-boards full leather as a vernacular binding style; soon afterward, cloth case binding begins to predominate. This transitional time is also unique because it is the first time that the techniques, workshops, materials and tools of bookbinders were extremely well documented by multiple contemporaneous sources: Diderot, Dudin and Gauffencourt. Because of this documentation, it is possible to reconstruct rare or nonexistent tools, learn about fabrication techniques not visible when examining the books themselves, and understand more about the materials that constitute these bindings. By studying these aspects, we can appreciate how these somewhat minor points begin to relate to larger questions concerning the history of material culture, conservation and preservation issues, the history of craft, the transmission of textual information, and, of course, the history of bookbinding.

.

ASPECTS OF LATE 18TH CENTURY FRENCH BOOKS

  • These books have been beaten by hand, according to Dudin, eight(!) times: the sheets are beaten before folding, then after folding, the boards are beat on the inside, the cords are beat after lacing, the spine is backed, the turn ins are beaten before covering, the outside of the boards and joint is beaten after covering and the corners are beaten on the inside before delivering the book.
  • Endleaves are commonly a white folio wrapped around a marbled or plain one.
  • Sewing is often on 5-7 raised cords.
  • Boards are cut less than 90 degrees at the joint. Typically large backcornering.
  • The book is backed after the boards are laced on.
  • Lacing is almost always through 3 holes, then cross-mounted, at least at the head and tail.
  • Edges are most often colored or sprinkled, usually red.
  • Spines have parchment, goldbeaters skin, or paper transverse linings extending onto boards. First class work uses a comb type liner.
  • Endbands have a rolled paper core, often blue and white.
  • The leather is usually decorated (sprinkled, stained or marbled) by the binder. Cheaper work was made with pre-decorated leather purchased by the binder.

.

COMMON MATERIAL AND STRUCTURAL PROBLEMS

  • Endband cores are usually stiff, detached, cracked, broken or lost. Often only two or three tiedowns.
  • Leather surface is often brittle, fragile and deteriorated. Grain surface often peels off like sheep. Multiple applications of Aqua Fortis (aka. Nitric Acid), mixed with wax and oil can cause complex interactions. Sometimes the leather detaches from the boards. Makes tissue repairs on the surface inadvisable without lifting.
  • Covering leather is often stiff and does not move very much. Opening the book can crack the joint.
  • Spine often immobile- book will not stay open without excessive force for consultation or exhibition. Often very heavy applications of glue and paste on the spine. Rapid and crude backing sometimes forces endsheets onto the outer face of the boards, causing the board to hinge from this point. Using a grattoir damages the signatures.
  • Caps usually badly damaged or missing.
  • Leather on the spine is often very thin, fragile and difficult to lift.
  • Title or volume labels are often missing, fragmentary or detaching.
  • Parchment transverse spine linings sometimes pull away, along with pastedown, from inner face of the board.
  • Sewing cords are often weak and brittle.
  • Tooling is often so lightly and quickly impressed, that gold flakes off.
  • Pulp boards are extremely difficult to split, and can loose chunks unpredictably. Due to the beating, they rarely are planar, easily distort and change dramatically in thickness.

.

RECOMMENDED READING

Cundall, Joseph. On Bookbindings: Ancient and Modern. London: George Bell and Sons, 1881.

Darnton, Robert. The Great Cat Massacre and other Episodes in French Cultural History. Basic Books: New York, 1984.

Diderot’s Bookbinding plates with English Translation of the terms by Denis Gouey. bookbinding.net

Dudin, M. The Art of the Bookbinder and Gilder. The Elmente Press: Leeds, England. 1977.

Eagan, Jane. ‘Board Making in Lalande’s Art du cartonnier‘ in Looking at Paper: Evidence & Interpretation, Canadian Conservation Institute, Toronto, 1999.

Encyclopedie Methodique. Encyclopedie Methodique, ou par ordre de matieres, par une Societe de Gens de letters, de Savans, et d’Artistes. Paris, Panckoucke et Agasse, 1790.

Foot, Mirjam M. Bookbinders at Work: Their Roles and Methods. The British Library and Oak Knoll Press, London and New Castle, DE, 2006.

Gauffecourt, Jean-Vincent Capronnier de. Traite de la Relieure des Livres: A Bilingual Treatise on Bookbinding. W. Thomas Taylor, Austin, 1987.

Hobsbawm, Eric. The Age of Revolution, 1789-1848. Vintage Books, New York, 1996.

Pollard, Graham and Esther Potter. Early Bookbinding Manuals: An Annotated list of Technical Accounts of Bookbinding to 1840. Oxford: Oxford Bibliographical Society, 1984.

Salaman, R.A.. Dictionary of leather-working tools c. 1700-1950. London: George Allen & Utwin, 1986.

Smith, Godfrey. The Laboratory of School of Arts. In The History of Bookbinding Technique and Design. Garland Publishing, Inc. New York and London, 1990.

Uzanne, Octave. The French Bookbinders of the Eighteenth Century. Chicago: Caxton Club, 1904.

Wolf, Richard. Marbled Paper: Its History, Techniques and Patterns. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1990.

.

FRENCH-ENGLISH/ ENGLISH-FRENCH TRANSLATIONS OF TERMS

Barber, G. ‘Le vocabulaire francais de la reliure au dix-huitieme siecle’, in De Liris compactis miscellanea, Bibliotheca Wittockiana: Brussels, 1984. (pp. 391-413)

CABBAG: cbbag.ca/ResourceListsWeb/TranslationOfTerms.html

Cloonan, Michele V. Early Bindings in Paper. G.K. Hall and Co., Boston, 1991. (pp. 108-116)

Dudin, M. The Art of the Bookbinder and Gilder. The Elmente Press: Leeds, England. 1977. (pp. 89-94)

Foot, Mirjam M. Bookbinders at Work: Their Roles and Methods. The British Library and Oak Knoll Press, London and New Castle, DE, 2006. (Appendix II, pp. 151-4)

Worterbuch, Max Hettler Verlag: Stuttgart, 1969. (German, English, French, Italian)

.

NOTES ON MATERIALS

BOARDS – So far the closest board I’ve come up with is laminating with PVA (yes, I know… but paste tends to delaminate when beating) 4 ply matboard with a sheet of blotter on each side. It gives a lightweight feel, but compresses to half the original thickness when beating.

EDGE COLORING – I use AYTEX-P, they used flour paste.  Two heaping tablespoons per 200 ml. Water, heat in double boiler until thick and turns translucent. Mix with vermillion, a little water and a few drops of vinegar and a little alum. According to Gauffencourt, “…until all is well mixed & neither too thick nor too thin.” Given the large number of variables when preparing and applying the coloring, this is surprisingly accurate advice!

SPRINKLING – Quick method2 parts Fe(II), 2 parts Tannin, 30 parts cheap red (lots of tannins) wine. Heat about 15 min, then seems to be ready in an hour or so.

GLAIRING – Just egg white, a little clean water if it is too sticky.

.

SHARPENING: REMEMBER THESE FOUR B I T S OF INFORMATION

B = BURR. You need to feel the burr before moving to the next finer grit, not matter what sharpening system you are using. If you do not feel the burr, the back and the bevel are not meeting and the knife will never be sharp

I = I WOULDN’T ROUND THE BEVEL, IF I WERE YOU. It will create an obtuse bevel that will not cut.

T = THIRTEEN DEGREES. This seems to be the close to ideal for paring vegetable tanned and tawed binding leathers.

S = SCRATCHES IN THE METAL. Examine the scratch pattern by slightly changing the angle you are holding the knife when sharpening. Make sure the new scratches extend to the cutting edge.

.

SOURCES FOR MATERIALS USED IN THIS PRESENTATION

Bradawl, Froittoir, Knives – Jeff Peachey, 212.387.7860, jeffpeachey.wordpress.com

Facsimile Sheet from Diderot’s Encyclopedie, 434.924.8851, rarebookschool.org

French Reproduction Finishing Tools– P&S Engraving, pandsengraving.co.uk

Iron (II) Sulfate and Vermillion– Kremer Pigments, 212.219.2394, kremerpigments.com

Leather (French Brown)– Pergamena, 845.649.5806, pergamena.net

Nitric Acid (aka. Aqua Fortis, Strong Water)- Don’t even think about it

Perfume, In The Library, 718.384.6890, cbihateperfume.com

Quebracho Bark Tan– Van Dyke Supply Co., 800.843.3320, vandyketaxidermy.com

Text Paper- Zerkhall Ingres Ivory #606, NY Central, 212.473.7705, nycentralart.com

Yew Wood Folders– Jim Croft, 208.245.3043

This font is Didot, a French typeface circa. 1784-1811

Grattoir

dudin scraper

Fig. 1: Two grattoirs from Dudin, Plate 10.

In 18th century French bookbinding, according to both Diderot and Dudin, these grattoirs (usually translated as scrapers) were used to aid in backing and smooth the spine linings. There were also frottoirs (versions with dents– pointed teeth) [*check comments for some discussion of these terms*] to scratch up the spine to get better adhesion, since book structures of this time period often had transverse vellum spine linings.  I made a wood copy of the tool above on the left, but the light weight and friction from the wood made it awkward and ineffective; the friction would tend to tear the spinefolds and dislodge spine linings. There is a contemporary version, available commercially, which is even more useless due to the extreme round on the ends.  I’m a little uncertain about these terms– so far the only reference I’ve found in English is in Diehl, where she refers to a wood frottoir ( burnisher?), that looks a lot like the one still available.

frottoir

Fig. 2: Two 19th century  frottoir/grattoirs, courtesy Ernst Rietzschel.

This summer,  I had a chance to test drive the combination frottoir/ grattoir tools pictured above. Ernst Rietzschel, from Holland, borrowed them from his bookbinding teacher in Belgium,  so it is likely they come from the French binding tradition.  Their weight, as well as the very slight curve,  made it easy to concentrate pressure on just a signature of two for accurate manipulation of the spine. As an unexpected benefit, it was wildly cathartic to punch and  scratch the spinefolds with the teeth, of course, only in the interests of historical research!

I used the smooth, slightly rounded ends of the original tool to back the book and to align the cords as well as to burnish the spine linings. Even with the damaged edges and paint, I was surprised how easy it was to gently control the backing process and tweak the cords into alignment.   I had much more control compared to using a hammer, and it was quicker (and potentially less damaging) than loading the spine with so much moisture that I could manipulate it with my fingers or a folder.

Originally, I was planning to reproduce the original, but I didn’t want to make it out of iron because it is prone to rust.  I wanted two smooth ends since I only scrape spines on specific historical models.  I considered stainless steel, but didn’t have any on hand, and it is very gummy and difficult to work by stock reduction.  Bronze was a good candidate, but brass is slightly harder.

So I made a modern interpretation out of  free machining, type 360 brass with a lignum vitae handles.  The quarter inch thick brass and heavy wood handles give it a weight similar to the original, although the aesthetics are quite different. My version is 1.5 inches wide, 8 inches long and weighs 9.4 oz. ( 4 cm wide, 20 long, and 266 grams) In practice it works just as well, in not better, than the original.  It can be grasped with a fist for extra pressure, or delicately held like a pencil for detailed manipulation.

I wonder why a tool this useful would become virtually extinct?

frottoir2

Fig. 3: A contemporary grattoir I designed and made.